Monday, May 11, 2015

PB3A

              Cinzia Pica-Smith and Timothy A. Poynton’s peer-reviewed journal entry entitled, “Supporting Interethnic and Interracial Friendships Among Youth to Reduce Prejudice and Racism in Schools: The Role of the School Counselor,” focuses on eliminating prejudices that exist even among children in elementary schools and “improving social, emotional, and cultural competence among [these] youth” (Pica-Smith, Poynton). In order to generate two separate genres stemming from this single journal entry, there must be two distinct audiences for which they are intended.
              The first of these audiences is the young childrenespecially those attending an elementary schoolthat are the prominent subject of the original article. While it would be inappropriate (and likely far too advanced) to straightforwardly discuss issues of prejudice and racism with young children, they would likely respond well to the detailed pictures of a storybook. Popular children’s books include the Junie B. Jones series, the Charlie and Lola series, the A to Z Mysteries series, and the Clifford, The Big Red Dog series; the covers of each of these are depicted with young, white children as their protagonists. While the young students likely do not pick up on this consciously, “same-race friendship preferences begin in preschool (Fishbein, 1996; Fishbein & Imai, 1993; Rutland, Cameron, Bennett, & Ferrell, 2005), [and] overall, interracial friendships decrease while intra-racial friendships increase as children grow older (Aboud et al., 2003; Kawabata & Crick, 2008)” (Pica-Smith, Poynton). Transforming the basis of Pica-Smith and Poynton’s journal entry into a story in which youthful, relatable characters of multiple races and ethnicities interact, playing outside, learning from each other, and spending time in each other’s homes would relay the anti-prejudice concept to children without them even realizing the situation at hand. These stories must include detailed, applicable pictures and emphasize that regardless of the activity, the children are engaging in it together. Each page will contain no more than a few simple sentences, allowing for the children to understand it. It must, however, contain a sufficiently complex and interesting storyline in order to maintain the interest of the young student.
              The second audience that the new genre must be tailored to appeal to is the teachers, counselors, and other staff members of the elementary school. Holding a workshop or event that each of the faculty members must attend, in which informational handouts pertaining to destroying the gap between students of different races and ethnicities are distributed, would strongly relate to the issue discussed in the scholarly publication. These handouts would include suggestions on how to go about closing this gap, such as, “school counselors must be willing to openly discuss issues of race and racism, prejudice, and discrimination with students and adults in the school community to support the optimal intergroup contact needed to facilitate intergroup friendships” (Pica-Smith, Poynton). They would also include graphs and tables of statistics displaying the results of research, perhaps pertaining to findings that “linked collaborative learning and teaching strategies in the classroom to increases in interracial and interethnic friendship and prejudice reduction” (Zirkel 2008). The handouts will touch on aspects of pathos, in the hopes of convincing faculty membersespecially teachers and counselors who deal directly with studentsof the reasons WHY they should want to eliminate prejudices; they are the ones that see on a daily basis how the students are impacted by their environments, and they probably do not enjoy observing bullying and hearing racist remarks. The handouts will serve as a reminder that it is the job of the faculty member to take action to prevent these occurrences. 

2 comments:

  1. I really like how both of them are found in the education realm. I think its interning that students can be reading these books then they can participate in workshops with the same topic. The book would be cute if it started with younger kids and then show them grow up together just to show how throughout the years race still doesn't matter and they don't let it ever mess with their friendship. What age group would the workshops be directed to? Would they continue all through schooling or just be directed at a certain age group? How would these instructions for the teachers address racism in schools too? Like how should they handle it either within or outside of the workshops? Just a few things to think about! Overall very cute!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am also interested in the topic you chose for your possible WP3 project, it sounds like a good topic to do a genre transformation! I liked how the genre transformations also related with your topic, children’s picture book and classroom workshop handouts. Not only did your examples that showed your understanding of children’s picture books gave me nostalgia (Junie B. Jones was a must-read growing up!), but you have also given good points about how the picture book engages the child’s attention until the end, which is super important. As for your genre transformation for the older generation, I liked how you are thinking to include the graphs and statistics from your scholarly piece into your creation. By doing so, it adds credibility and it has been done in most professional presentations. I feel like you have a pretty good grasp on the topic and you seem to be on point!

    ReplyDelete